Christmas is coming and so it must be time for another Beatles album.
Sigh.
It’s the music industry gift that keeps on giving, and giving and giving.
Punters need product. The Beatles industry of the 21st Century is booming far better than it ever was some sixty years ago.
And so for the 2025 Christmas market, we have Anthology 4, plus three more episodes of the Anthology telly series - y’know, the one that was the definitive tale of The Beatles back in 1996, that ended with The Threetles together again and a full stop on all things Fab Four.
Or Three.
So there.
I’m a tight arse and so haven’t forked out to stream the updated episodes. I have listened to Anthology 4 in one sitting.
tl;dr we don’t really need this.
Who would have thought?
Unlike Anthologies 1-3, the fourth instalment takes songs across all thirteen of the original albums. It’s basically a Best of the Bootlegs.
It starts off being a whole lotta fun with some goofing around in the studio by four very ambitious young men. It ends with AI stodge.
The goofy shit is great. Bands tend to goof a lot. We watched The Roses documentary last week after the news of Mani’s passing. My theory is that band goofing is good for the Them Vs Us music industry mentality.
But back to The Beatles.
You need to be an obsessive to recognise some of the slight differences compared to the original songs. Which defeats the whole point of unreleased rarities. You might as well listen to the originals.
The Beatles barrel is being scraped here.
But what a barrel.
You’re listening to songs that are staples of 20th Century culture. You are over-familiar with what follows.
Imagine listening - or even recording - these songs when they were completely unknown in our popular culture.
It’s hard to appreciate the outstanding qualities of the songs, given that you hear them every other day, given the relentless Beatles industry.
In My Life stands out amongst an incredibly crowded field of absolute monumental songs.
But halfway through, Anthology 4 starts to fall apart a little. The instrumental of Nowhere Man is bland. The strength is in the picture painted by the lyrics.
On the other hand, She’s Leaving Home works as an instrumental. It’s a rare case of the lyrics adding a little too much sorrow to an already downbeat arrangement.
Eggman sounds extra dramatic. You can imagine the instrumental working well on a horror soundtrack with all the stabbing strings.
The Something instrumental is… quite something.
Anthology 4 finishes off with the AI Beatles. Free as a Bird and Real Love benefit from a little extra production boost. But it’s still Beatles by numbers.
I actually quite liked Now and Then when it was released as the 2024 Beatles Inc release.
It closes the chapter on The Beatles for one final time.
Yeah, right.
Beatles AI will keep the business going for decades.