To Moving Image! …on a damp and miserable Tuesday evening.
The other option was to watch the serial CHEATERS Manchester City on the telly. Wisely we opted for a documentary film exploring different ideas about farming and wildlife.
Country life, innit.
Being screened in the village cinema was Derek Vs Derek. I didn’t realise this was a documentary until I pulled up the trailer earlier in the day.
The basic premise is a couple of farmers living not so neighbourly side by side down in Cornwall. One of them is the more traditional intensive farmer type, whilst the other wants to explore ideas and concepts related to rewilding the land.
Never the twain shall meet, etc.
This was a beautifully shot film. Right from the opening scenes some of the drone footage was stunning, showing the harvest coming in for the more traditional type of farming.
It didn’t take long for the two ideologies to start to clash. As the title of the film suggests, both farmers were called Derek.
This was just a setup to explain what was to come. Derek, the idealist, had his land bordering three other local farmers who were also opposed to the ground zero approach he was taking to the land.
This wasn’t so much a film all about ideologies. It also explored the intricacies of human nature and conflict resolution.
Derek the rewilder explained in detail how his love for this type of approach could be traced back to a childhood memories of reading the Ladybird Book of Wildlife. It was almost his bible as he then put into practise what was to come in his later life.
“He tells me I need to broaden my mind but I don’t want to fucking broaden my mind!”
…was the response for the meat and two veg, Derek.
An interesting subplot that was then played out was the more sympathetic approach from the wife of Derek, the traditionalist. She was very playful and lived up to any stereotypes of a farmer’s wife.
However she was open to new ideas and had a gloriously cheeky glint in her eye when she gently prodded her husband to try and understand what rewilding and a return to nature might achieve.
Derek the rewilder then raved on endlessly about beavers and how they are the workhorse for any project. It was fascinating to see how reintroducing them to the land had major consequential and positive environmental effects on the whole area.
Perhaps my favourite quote from the film came from Derek the traditionalist:
“That man’s a fucking psychopath when it comes to his hedges.”
The same could be said of me when I’m let loose with my chainsaw.
I was broadly sympathetic towards director rewilder. In fact the film was pretty much set up to try and convert you over, as Derek the traditionalist was also being framed as the one who needed to change his ways.
A tipping point in the film, and also for the local community, was the conference that Derek the rewilder held about reintroducing wolves into England.
This seemed like a step too far and offered up plenty of metaphors of a wolf in sheep’s clothing.
It was a fantastic film although it was often reduced to an A-level type essay argument of hHere are the pros, here are the cons, and I don’t really have a conclusion but let’s just see what happens.
It was better than staying in and watching the serial CHEATERS Manchester City.
The ending was really quite sweet. There are no spoilers to give away here apart from noting that a begrudging respect was the conclusion for both Dereks, as they could see the pros and cons of their opposite approaches.
It’s all about the common ground in it.
Christ there you go. I’ve become a bloody centrist.






























